The Wild Ponies of Assateague:
A Tale of Two Islands

by Louisa Amirault

...Continued from Page One

It was then that my husband put down the child carrier (yes, he did this long day with a 27 pound child on his back) and ran off to find an ATM.  Here is some IMPORTANT ADVICE: Bring Cash!  A good number of places on Chincoteague, including the carnival, do not take credit or debit cards.  To get food or water at the carnival, you need cash.  ATM’s are sparce on the island, and they aren’t always in service, as my husband discovered. Oh well, no water for us.

He made it back just in time to see the ponies come cantering in.  The Saltwater Cowboys were yelling and hooting, as they cracked their whips.  They herded the excited equines into the pens and were swallowed by the crowd.  Everyone wanted photos with the cowboys.  Even my baby was acting star struck, trying to reach out of her backpack and touch them.   

I let the family sleep in on Thursday morning, because Wednesday was so exhausting.  The auction was starting at 8 am, so I didn’t waste time with food or a shower.  I quietly whispered to my husband that I was going to rent a bike and go down to the auction by myself.  However, at 6:45 am, the rental shop was not yet open.  I headed down the road on foot, figuring that I’d try the next bike rental place.  Well, that wasn’t open either.  Alrighty then, I’ll just walk.  I have legs.  I pulled out a little crumpled map from my pocketbook and tried to find my way. 

I arrived a few minutes late, due to a wrong turn.  Here is another IMPORTANT TIP: Try to reserve special seating if you want to see the auction.  I couldn’t see a thing!  Luckily, I had a video camera with a screen, and was able to get a “periscope view”.  I held my camera over my head and angled the screen down.  As I looked around, I saw other people doing the same thing. 

Most of the foals auctioned off were about 3-4 months old, but some were as young as a month.  The young foals, though able to be auctioned, had to remain with their dams until fall.   I didn’t realize they had fall pick-ups…this was tempting.  No, no more horses.  My husband would kill me.  I want that palomino filly!  She is perfect!  I’ll bet she goes for at least 2K.  Nope, she went for $1100. 

Ponies were selling for about $1300 each.  Some of the plain foals went for as little as $850, while the black and white paints were going for about $3,000.  However, once you factor in the selling prices of the buy-back foals, the average sale was $2,431. 

A buy-back foal is a foal that the Chincoteague Volunteer Firemen's Association has hand-picked to go back to Assateague to populate the herd.  Anyone who bids on a buy-back foal, does so with the understanding that the foal will be returned to the island where it will stay for the rest of its life.  A buy-back foal can never be auctioned off.  The foal will remain the property of the Chincoteague Volunteer Firefighters, and the bid is basically a donation.  Most years, the buy-backs are fillies.  This year, the herd needed stallions.

Since 2001, a group of women from around the country, called the Buy-Back Babes, have been putting their money together to bid on these buy-back foals.  Keeping the heard strong is their mission.  This is the first year that they were able to bid on stallions, which was exciting for them.  The Buy-Back Babes made history at this auction, when they purchased a young stallion for $17,500!  The crowd was in awe.  Until now, the most ever paid for a Chincoteague Pony was $10,000, back in 2001. 

A woman from Washington, who was actively bidding against the Buy-Back Babes, also surpassed the 2001 record when she bought a foal for $11,200.  It was the last buy-back of the day.  Allowing a foal to remain on Assateague for life is very important to buy-back bidders, and they enjoy being able to take part in the island’s history. 

Seventy-one foals were auctioned off this year, totaling $177,250 for the fire company.  Even though there were fewer sales this year, nearly $10,000 more was generated from the auction. 

Not wanting to walk an hour back to the hotel, I called my husband to come pick me up.  I needed blueberry pancakes, and I needed them bad.  We had some breakfast and did some shopping on Main Street.  We needed to get souvenirs for our parents before leaving the next day.

Main Street has a nice statue of Misty, the famous pony from the book, Misty of Chincoteague.  I wanted my daughter to sit for a picture in front of the Misty statue, but she was distracted by someone in a large, purple horse costume.  His name was Walter, The Purple Pony, and he was doing a book signing at the nearby library.  A man (the author?) was reading Walter's book out loud to the children.  We had to join in.  They gave us free copies of his book and an autograph too. My husband suggested that we cross the street to visit the t-shirt shop Walter hailed from, The Purple Pony.  The Purple Pony did their own printing, and the shirts were much softer than the standard merchandise that we found at all the other gift shops.  My little one reached into a bin of purple stuffed ponies and started hugging her selection.  Two shirts for myself: $29.98. One stuffed Walter: $14.95.  A happy child on vacation: priceless! 

After a swim and hot-tub soak back at the Refuge Inn, we talked about adding another night onto our stay.  I didn’t think it was a good idea, because I was getting more attached to the island each day.  I knew I had to make myself stick to the original plan before leaving was even harder. 

On Friday morning, we checked out and headed back to the fairgrounds to say goodbye to the ponies that were left in the heard. Someone told us that we had just missed a bunch of ponies swimming home to Assateague.  However, all the buy-back and fall pick-up foals were still at the fairgrounds with their dams.  Before my eyes, they were all released into the empty paddock in front of me.  If you’ve ever seen a foal kicking up his or her heels and jumping all over his dam, you know how much fun it is to watch.  Now, picture about 20 foals all running around and jumping on each other.  That was so much fun! 

For the first time, I could see them clearly without having to stand on my toes or reach my camera over my head.  A few were noticeably clean from their Wednesday swim.  Most were still nursing, so they didn’t have the big bloated bellies that the rest of the herd had from eating the salty marsh grass.  They were beautiful.  There was a very spirited paint with two blue eyes with undying energy.  He had a bandage on his ankle from an injury he sustained during the swim.  Clearly it wasn't an issue for him.  Another that caught my eye was a quiet bay paint with the marking of a horse head on his shoulder…it looked like a self portrait. 

Leaving the island was depressing.  “Just follow the Trip-Tik,” I told my husband.  It didn’t matter where we stopped on the way back.  I wasn’t looking forward to going home at all.  It wasn’t until I saw a sign for Sonic in Delaware, that I perked up.  Wow, they really do exist!  My Chocolate Cream Pie Shake and my husband’s Cookie Dough Blast lived up to our expectations. That Sonic better still be there next year, because we are coming back to Chincoteague and Assateague!

Helpful Chincoteague and Assateague Links if you are planning to visit:

Chincoteague Chamber of Commerce (chincoteague.net)

Assateague Island National Seashore

Assateague State Park

The Town of Chincoteague

The Refuge Inn

Chincoteague Pony Center

 


Return to EquineSite.com Homepage